Stroud West

Maureen Rutter - Labour County Councillor for Stroud West

labour

My Photo
Name:

I am the Labour County Councillor for Stroud West, which covers Cainscross, Farmhill and Paganhill. I am the Labour Group Leader in Gloucestershire County Council.

 

You can contact me by e mail at maureen.rutter@gloucestershire.gov.uk or telephoning me on 01453 759365.

Friday, June 02, 2006

Consultation on Mental Health services in Gloucestershire

Letter to the Stroud News and Journal

Dear Madam

May I please take the opportunity, through your columns to say what I was not able to say last night at the so called consultation meeting with the Gloucestershire Partnership NHS Trust, which is the body responsible for mental health services in Gloucestershire. For some reason, despite the fact I was sitting directly opposite him in the front row, and had my hand up from the start, the chair, Robert Maxwell, steadfastly refused to call me, in spite of there being calls from the floor eventually to hear what I had to say. I do after all represent thousands of people in the Cainscross area of Stroud and have many years of experience of social services as they affect the community.

I wished to ask several questions, for instance, they are very vague about the services for children and adolescents (CAMHS), which in any case are totally inadequate now, also the point which was made very forcibly several times by other speakers about what constitutes ‘treatment’. The loss of day care services, and chances for group work, will be felt by any member of the community who has used these services, and by their carers. Carers too are looking at a loss of respite and rehabilitation services which will severely curtail their abilities to continue to care. Whatever else is removed these services are vital and more resources have been needed in this area for a long time. Pills, as one of the audience remarked, are not the whole answer to clinical care, what about counselling? social help? anything which works against the isolation often experienced by anybody with mental heath needs? This is a big part of the cure for adults of working age who are the client group taking the brunt of the proposed cuts. At present Social Services do not have the budget available to pick up the shortfall.

I noticed at one point Geoff James, the chief executive of the Trust who was explaining the situation to us with the aid of slides talk of developing community based services. Isn’t it a bit late to talk about developing services which ought to have already been developed. The Trust has been in existence now for four years and there has been plenty of opportunity for them to be further ahead than they are now in service development.

This is all unacceptable, I understand they have to balance their books but all the proposals in the consultation document are basically unacceptable and will lead to serious consequences for people at present using the services. Mental health is, and always has been, the Cinderella of the Health Service, inadequately resourced, and old fashioned in its approach to care.

May I say it is not the business of the community to suggest where cuts should come, we are not NHS managers and for myself in view of the Council having a new administration I no longer have the ability to affect things from a Social Services point of view. I know hard work has been done and some cooperation achieved but it is not enough to prevent hardship now.

I do not disagree with the governments approach to more community based services, but sadly this has not happened, the will to do so has been there but the ability seems to have been lacking. People are saying this is a forgone conclusion and does not deserve the name of a consultation.

We need much better mental health services that we have at present, and we must make our voices heard to the Trust, the Strategic Health Authority, Patricia Hewitt and anyone else we can think of who might be able to make a difference to the alternatives being presented to us here.

There are many questions unanswered as far as I am concerned. I remain feeling aggrieved that I did not have the chance to put those questions last night. I will make sure that I ask them in writing.